The Best Medicine:
Evidence-Based Health Care
(November 2008)
The medical care you receive should be based on the
latest scientific evidence. Here’s how to make sure it is.
You can buy the newest model car.
You can read the latest novel, or wear
the latest styles. But when it comes
to maintaining true quality of life,
nothing beats getting health care that’s
based on the latest, greatest evidence.
When the treatment you receive
is “evidence-based,” that means a
solid body of research has concluded
the given treatment is highly recommended
for someone in your situation.
Evidence-based medicine means
getting the health care services you
need right when you need them to
ensure the best possible results. It
also means not receiving unnecessary
tests or treatments that are more
likely to harm you than help you.
Informed Decisions
“It doesn’t matter what medical
school doctors graduate from; it matters
whether they use the best available
evidence in making decisions
for their patients,” explains Jean R.
Slutsky, director of the Center for
Outcomes and Evidence of the
Agency for Healthcare Research
and Quality in Rockville, Md.
Unfortunately, prescribing
many medications, medical
tests, and other treatments
doesn’t always reflect the
evidence on how they
should be used. Slutsky
points out that if every
doctor practiced evidence-
based medicine,
we would see similar
trends in treatment all across the
U.S. However, treatments for certain
conditions tend to vary, not just from
provider to provider, but also from
region to region.
The Patient ’s Role
To help ensure the treatment you
receive is evidence-based:
- Make your health care providers’
job easier: Provide all the information
you can to help them make
the right diagnoses and treatment
decisions.
- Ask good questions.
“Don’t try to second-guess your
doctor,” Slutsky advises. “However,
do inquire what the scientific evidence
has to offer about any test or
treatment being prescribed.”
You might ask:
- What are the benefits and risks
of this treatment or medical test?
- Why are you recommending
this for me?
- What will happen if I don’t have
this treatment or medical test?
- Are there other treatments I
might consider instead?
- Become informed about your
condition and its recommended
treatments. Do some research at
the library or on the Internet. Just
be sure to consult reliable Web sites;
these may include sites sponsored by
nationally recognized nonprofit groups,
such as www.americanheart.org,
or by the U.S. government, such as
http://medlineplus.gov.
- Compare the care your doctor
is prescribing with what’s widely
recommended according to the
evidence.
Be aware that certain medical tests
are often overprescribed, particularly
in people with no symptoms or
related risk factors; for example,
chest X-ray, urinalysis, full-body
CT scan, complete blood count, and
ECGs (electrocardiogram). Unless
your condition or risk factors call for
such tests, the risks or expense of
having them are likely to outweigh
the potential benefits.
- Ask for an explanation if you’re
not receiving the recommended care,
or you suspect the care you’re prescribed
might be unnecessary. Yo
personal risk factors or symptoms
may call for the treatment plan, but
it never hurts to ask. If the answer
leaves you with doubts about the care
you’re receiving, consider seeking a
second opinion.
- Choose a physician with the
right training and experience for
your condition.
- Ensure any hospital you visit is
accredited by The Joint Commission.
Visit www.jointcommission.org to
find out the hospital’s experience and
success rates in treating your condition.
- Check online rating services,
such as www.leapfroggroup.org or
www.healthgrades.com, to ensure a
hospital or doctor has received high
marks for quality of care.
“Most important, be an informed
consumer and a partner in your
health care,” Slutsky stresses. “As a
patient, have questions formulated in
your mind before you meet with your
doctor. Let your doctor know what’s
important to you and what your
values are as a person.”
Helpful Resources
Questions Are the Answer: Get More
Involved with Your Health Care. This
practical resource of the Agency for
Healthcare Research and Quality
(AHRQ) can help you build your own
list of questions to ask based on the
type of visit or health care decision
you’ll be making before your next visit
with your doctor. Check it out—and
print out your personalized list—at
www.ahrq.gov, search for “Questions
are the Answer.”
Summary guides for consumers.
You can review the evidence-based
treatment for various conditions
at the Web site of the AHRQ. Visit
www.effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov, and click on “Summary Guides”
(for consumers). There are guides
for treatment of localized prostate
cancer, gastroesophageal reflux
disease (GERD ), and osteoporosis; as
well as guidelines for people taking
medications for high blood pressure,
depression, pain, rheumatoid arthritis,
and more.
MedlinePlus Guide to Healthy Web
Surfing. This service of the U.S.
National Library of Medicine and
the National Institutes of Health
offers tips for safely researching
medical conditions online. Visit
http://medlineplus.gov and search
for “Healthy Web Surfing.”
National Guideline Clearinghouse.
This Web page provides links to
many Internet sites featuring
science-based health information.
Go to the Patient Resources page
at www.guideline.gov.
The main Web site of the National
Institutes of Health links you to information
on many health topics. Visit
www.nih.gov.
Polly Turner spoke with Jean R. Slutsky, director of the Center for Outcomes and Evidence of the
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality in Rockville, Md.
© StayWell Custom Communications. Information is the opinion of the sourced authors and organizations. Personal decisions regarding health, diet, and exercise should be made only after consultation with the reader's own medical advisers. This material may not be reproduced for redistribution without written permission from StayWell Custom Communications.